Ospreys-commissioned study says evidence does not support cutting Wales to three professional clubs
Archive article. Published on Fri 13 Nov, 10:07. Conditions may have changed since this reporting.

A Sheffield Hallam University study of 23 seasons of Welsh professional rugby has concluded that the evidence does not support reducing the number of professional clubs in Wales from four to three, according to the Ospreys, who commissioned and paid for it.
What the report says, per the Ospreys
- Seasons analysed
- 23
- Share of home league attendances from Welsh derbies, 2012 to 2026
- 48%
- Welsh derbies a season, four clubs
- 12
- Welsh derbies a season, three clubs
- 6
What the report says
The Welsh Rugby Data Report states: "The independent analysis of the data does not logically lead to a conclusion that the removal of one professional team in Wales is a strategic move grounded in evidence." Professor Keith Davids, one of its four authors, said: "In our view, the rationale for change is not supported by evidence. Narrowing down the pool of players into fewer locations will narrow down the competition pool." The Ospreys say the report finds that matches between the four Welsh clubs generated 48% of league attendances at home games in Wales from 2012 to 2026, and that with three clubs those fixtures would fall from twelve a season to six. It also describes a "bottleneck" of elite playing opportunities, with a greater risk of Welsh players moving to clubs outside Wales.
Who paid for it
The report was produced by the university's Sport and Physical Activity Research Centre and commissioned and paid for by Ospreys Rugby Limited. The club says the fee was fixed in advance and did not depend on the findings, and that the analysis and conclusions are the university's own. Alun Wyn Jones, the Ospreys' director of rugby, who chaired the working group that commissioned it, said: "We want four Clubs. This is not about one club's record against another's."
What happens next
From mid-November, the Ospreys say the club will send the final report to the Welsh Rugby Union board, its chief executive and the Professional Rugby Board, and ask for it to be placed before the Rugby Summit the union has announced. The club will also publish it in full, with its method and sources, by the end of November.
